The movie Les
Misérables
takes place in 19th century France, and is a story told
through music and singing about an ex- prisoner, and the determined
policeman who will not leave him alone (“Synopsis”). The ex-
prisoner then goes on to take in the daughter of a factory worker
turned prostitute. These events all occur during a time when France
was going through a hard time, and a revolution was brewing.
The movie Les Misérables,
which can be translated into “the wretched ones” or “the
outsiders” is based off of the novel by Victor Hugo which was
based off events that occurred in France from the years 1796 (when
Jean Valjean steals a loaf of bread and goes to prison) until the
June Revolution of 1832 (Alleyn). The
movie does depict Jean Valjean's experience in prison correctly, as
prisoners like Valjean “were imprisoned in galleys
that didn't go to sea, then moved to a prison called the Bagne”
(“Les Misérables movies”) which had horrible conditions.
Although the characters are fictional
(Roberts), the movie does portray some
of the events that occurred in France during this time period
accurately, but tends to oversimplify many parts of France's
struggles.
In 1793, throughout Maximilien de Robespierre's
“Reign of Terror” there were many wars and famines before
Napoleon Bonaparte took over France and ruled from 1804 until 1814.
It was only then that Louis XVIII assumed the throne of France, and
when he died, Charles X became king, although he “[was] soon exiled
in 1830 during the July Revolution, also known as the Second French
Revolution” (Bradford). Finally, Louis
Philippe d'Orléans began to rule France (Bradford
). The movie Les Miserables shows the June Revolution of 1832 against
the ruler Louis Philippe (von Tunzelmann
) despite the popular belief that it is about the French Revolution
of 1789 (von Tunzelmann) . However,
although the movie portrayed this correctly, they failed to show most
of the events that led up to the June Revolution and showed only that
revolution. Another aspect of inaccuracy in the movie is that the
movie makes a very huge deal of the June Revolution, leading viewers
to believe that it was a large part of French history, although in
reality it was relatively small, and not incredibly significant
(Maranzani ). During the time of the June Revolution, a “deadly
cholera epidemic had exacerbated a severe economic crisis” (“Enjoy
Les Misérables”) . This is shown accurately throughout the
movie with the hundreds of sick, poor people walking around town, and
with Fantine having to become a prostitute in order to bring in money
after being fired from her factory job. This accumulation of
poverty, as well as the death of General
Jean Maximilien Lamarque,
who had helped the poor was what triggered the revolution.
The movie
accurately showed how the huge mob of people accompanied Lamarque's
funeral procession, and “some witnesses claimed it eventually grew
to 100,000.”(“Enjoy
Les Misérables” ).
The movie also accurately depicted how barricades were used during
the revolution (“Enjoy
Les Misérables” ),
how most of the rebels were students (Maranzani ), and how the
citizens of Paris did not come and assist the rebels in their
revolution (“Enjoy Les Misérables”).
However, while the movie portrayed many of the events historically
accurately, the movie ends on a more happy, and hopeful note, which
gives viewers a different view on what actually happened (“Les Miz:
Mizleading”). The revolution caused most of the rebels to lose
their lives (“Enjoy
Les Misérables”)
and was a failure. It was not until sixteen years later that yet
another revolution got rid of Louis Philippe (Maranzani). The
director of the movie Les Misérables did manage to incorporate many
accurate aspects of French history into the musical movie. However,
the dramatic music, and the lack of historical background of what
occurred before the June Revolution of 1832, caused the movie to be
less accurate, and in some ways influenced the viewers to come to the
conclusion that the revolution ended well. In a similar way, the
movie focused on specific fictional characters rather than the
historical event that occurred, causing the viewers' attention to
shift away from the historical aspects of the movie.
Although
the film Les
Misérables,
based on the popular book by Victor Hugo, has many historically
accurate parts such as the funeral procession of Lemarque, and the
considerable amount of poverty in France during this time, the
extreme focus on this event, and only this event creates an
inaccurate perspective of France's history. The directors did not
include any of the other important events in France before the
revolution, that in fact was not very significant. Also, the music
throughout the entire movie makes the violent event seem more
romantic, and at the end of the movie, despite the failure of the
revolution, and many deaths, the movie ends on a hopeful note,
causing the viewers of the movie to see the event differently.
This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. Looking to reading your next post. buy dvd major crimes season 6
ReplyDeleteWow i can say that this is another great article as expected of this blog.Bookmarked this site.. buy dvd when calls the heart season 3
ReplyDeleteIt's a musical man not a historical documentry cut them some slack!
ReplyDeleteIt's a musical man not a documentary cut them some slack!
ReplyDelete